top of page
Kevin Miller

The Importance of a Unanimous Shareholder Agreement

Updated: Jul 19


Running a business in Manitoba, like anywhere else, involves careful planning and a solid understanding of legal frameworks. One critical legal document that often gets overlooked is the Unanimous Shareholder Agreement (USA). This document is essential for any company with multiple shareholders, as it lays out the rules and guidelines for decision-making, ownership transfer, and conflict resolution. A well-crafted USA, which includes provisions like a buy/sell agreement and a shotgun clause, can prevent many disputes and ensure smooth business operations.


Understanding the Unanimous Shareholder Agreement


A Unanimous Shareholder Agreement is a binding contract among all shareholders of a corporation. In Manitoba, this agreement can significantly impact how a company operates, as it outlines the roles, responsibilities, and rights of each shareholder. Here are key components that should be included in a USA:


  1. Buy/Sell Agreement: This clause stipulates how a shareholder's interest in the company can be bought or sold. It helps avoid disputes by providing a clear process for the transfer of shares in cases such as retirement, death, or voluntary exit.

  2. Shotgun Clause: Also known as a buy-sell clause, this provision allows a shareholder to offer their shares to another shareholder at a specified price. The other shareholder must then either accept the offer or sell their shares at the same price. This mechanism is crucial in deadlock situations, providing a clear resolution path.

  3. Funding through Insurance: Ensuring that the buy/sell agreement is funded properly with insurance is crucial. Life insurance and disability insurance can provide the necessary funds to buy out a shareholder who passes away or becomes incapacitated.


The Risks of Not Having a Properly Funded Agreement


Without a well-drafted USA and adequate insurance, businesses face several risks. Here are some examples of what can go wrong:


  1. Disputes Among Shareholders: Without clear guidelines, disagreements among shareholders can escalate into legal battles, draining resources and damaging the business's reputation.

  2. Financial Strain: If a buy/sell agreement is not funded with insurance, the company might struggle to buy out a deceased or incapacitated shareholder's stake. This financial strain can jeopardize the company’s stability and operations.

  3. Operational Disruptions: Shareholder disputes or the sudden need to buy out a shareholder can distract management and disrupt day-to-day operations, potentially leading to lost business opportunities and revenue.


Real-World Example


Consider a Manitoba-based manufacturing company with three shareholders. One of the shareholders unexpectedly passes away. Without a funded buy/sell agreement, the remaining shareholders must find the funds to buy out the deceased shareholder's interest. This may involve taking on debt, which can strain the company's finances and limit its growth potential. Moreover, the deceased shareholder’s family might become involved in business decisions, leading to potential conflicts if they do not share the same vision for the company.


Alternatively, if the company had a USA with a properly funded buy/sell agreement using life insurance, the insurance proceeds would provide the necessary funds to buy out the deceased shareholder's interest without financial strain. This allows the remaining shareholders to continue running the business smoothly, ensuring stability and continuity.


Legal Framework in Manitoba


In Manitoba, the Business Corporations Act provides the legal basis for shareholder agreements. The Act allows shareholders to create binding agreements that can override certain default rules of the Act, giving them greater control over the governance of their corporation. However, to be effective, these agreements must be unanimous and in writing.


Conclusion


A Unanimous Shareholder Agreement is a critical tool for any business with multiple shareholders. By including key provisions such as a buy/sell agreement and a shotgun clause, and ensuring these agreements are properly funded with insurance, businesses can protect themselves from potential disputes and financial difficulties. In Manitoba, where the legal framework supports such agreements, there is no reason for businesses to overlook this vital aspect of corporate governance. Ensuring that your company has a comprehensive and well-funded USA in place will provide peace of mind and stability, allowing you to focus on growing your business.

11 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page